Skip to main content
(855) 435-3666 Free Case Review → ES
Home  >  Recent Settlements  >  BMW  >  2024 BMW X5 — New Jersey
✦ Case Study: Resolved
$112,587 Vehicle Buyback
Results may vary. Prior outcomes do not guarantee a similar result. Each case is unique and depends on its specific facts and applicable law.

2024 BMW X5 Lemon Law Case Study: Buyback in New Jersey

Leased New in New Jersey
Free Case Review → Call (855) 435-3666
$112,587
Recovered
3 Visits
Repair Attempts
31 Days
Out of Service
9,220 Mi
At First Repair
Case Overview

New Jersey BMW X5 Case: 3 Repair Visits and 31 Days Out of Service

2024 BMW X5 lemon law buyback in New Jersey: Easy Lemon recovered $112,587 for this client after 3 repair visits and 31 days out of service. The claim was brought under New Jersey Lemon Law (N.J. Stat. §56:12-29 to §56:12-49). When the same defect keeps coming back and the manufacturer cannot fix it, the owner may be entitled to a buyback, a replacement or a cash settlement, at no cost†.

Our client leased this 2024 BMW X5 new in New Jersey. Its repair orders run from September 25, 2024 to November 26, 2025: 3 visits in all, and 31 days when it could not be driven. The first visit came at 9,220 miles.

BMW settled the claim with a vehicle buyback of $112,587. That figure includes our client's payment, the lender payoff and the attorney fees.

Systems Involved

  • Engine
  • Drivetrain/Axles
  • Steering
🔧
3
Repair Attempts
📅
31
Days Out of Service
🚗
9,220
Miles at First Repair
✓
$112,587
Recovered
Repair History

2024 BMW X5 Repair History: What the Repair Orders Show

Visit 1: September 25–October 18, 2024

  • The owner dropped off the vehicle and arranged their own transportation.
  • A complimentary multi-point inspection was completed.
  • Diagnostic work showed a drivetrain malfunction caused by faulty injectors in cylinders 5, 6, 7, and 8.
  • The technicians replaced the injectors, coils, plugs, and performed several tests including smoke, misfire, and mixture control calibrations.
  • The intake pressure sensor was swapped, oil and filter changed, and all faults were cleared.
  • After multiple road tests totalling about 175 miles, no warning lights appeared, and all systems tested normal.
  • The owner also reported a clicking sound when turning the steering wheel. The technicians cleaned the wheel bearing flanges, installed friction rings and verified that the sound was gone.
  • The vehicle was cleared for release.

Visit 2: February 25–28, 2025

  • The owner reported that the drivetrain warning light comes on while driving and the vehicle shakes.
  • The light sometimes turns off, but the shaking continues until the car is turned off for a few minutes.
  • Inspection found fouled spark plugs in cylinders 6, 7, and 8 caused by previously faulty injectors.
  • Performed diagnostic tests, swapped known good plugs, and completed multiple road tests.
  • After replacing spark plugs in cylinders 6 and 7, all faults were cleared and fuel adaptations reset.
  • The vehicle was road-tested again, and no shaking or drivability problems were present.

Visit 3: November 24–26, 2025

  • The owner reported that the CEL is on.
  • Technicians found misfire faults on all bank 2 cylinders caused by faulty fuel injectors, so they replaced all bank 2 spark plugs along with the fuel injectors for cylinders 5, 6 and 7.
Legal Analysis

Can a 2024 BMW X5 Be a Lemon in New Jersey?

New Jersey Lemon Law (N.J. Stat. §56:12-29 to §56:12-49) covers new motor vehicles purchased or leased in New Jersey for personal, family, or household use, and certain used vehicles.

  • Repair attempts: 3 repair attempts for the same defect (or 1 for serious safety defects)
  • Days out of service: 20 cumulative calendar days
  • Remedies: Replacement vehicle, full refund, or cash settlement
  • Attorney fees: Yes - manufacturer pays consumer's attorney fees if consumer prevails
This case: Across 3 repair visits, the BMW X5 spent 31 days out of service. The federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act also applies to written warranties nationwide. Part of the attorney fees came out of the settlement.
Our Approach

How Was This BMW X5 Lemon Law Claim Resolved?

1

Free Case Review

We reviewed the repair orders from September 25, 2024 to November 26, 2025 and tallied both the number of visits and the days the BMW X5 stayed with the dealer.

2

Building the File

Each visit went into a timeline with the complaint, what the technician found and what was repaired, grouped by system (engine, drivetrain/axles and steering).

3

Demand to BMW

BMW received our written demand, with the repair history attached, asking for a buyback.

4

Vehicle Buyback

The claim settled as a vehicle buyback of $112,587.

Case Status

$112,587 Vehicle Buyback Secured

$112,587
Vehicle Buyback: Manufacturer Repurchase

Key Case Facts

  • Vehicle: 2024 BMW X5
  • Leased in: New Jersey
  • Status at lease: New
  • Mileage at first repair: 9,220 miles
  • Systems involved: Engine, Drivetrain/Axles, Steering
  • Repair attempts: 3 visits
  • Days out of service: 31 days
  • Manufacturer: BMW
  • Settlement type: Vehicle Buyback
  • Settlement amount: $112,587 (Buyback)
Client Reviews

What Our Clients Are Saying

Legal Team

Attorney on Record

Steven Nassi, Esq. - Managing Partner

Steven Nassi, Esq.

Managing Partner, Easy Lemon by RockPoint Law P.C.

Licensed attorney whose practice is limited to lemon law. Steven leads the Easy Lemon legal team and has overseen thousands of successful lemon law claims against major manufacturers including Audi, Volkswagen, Mercedes-Benz, BMW, and more.

Having Problems With Your BMW X5?

A BMW X5 that keeps returning to the dealer with the same defect may be a lemon under New Jersey law. Getting a free case evaluation takes about 30 seconds.

Qualify in 30 Seconds →
Common Questions

2024 BMW X5 Lemon Law Questions in New Jersey

How does New Jersey lemon law apply to a BMW X5?
The New Jersey Lemon Law (N.J. Stat. §56:12-29 to §56:12-49) uses a standard of 3 repair attempts for the same defect (or 1 for serious safety defects), or 20 cumulative calendar days out of service. Remedies: Replacement vehicle, full refund, or cash settlement. Written warranties are also covered nationwide by the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act.
What was the settlement amount for this 2024 BMW X5?
A vehicle buyback totaling $112,587. Part went to our client, part paid off the lender, and the rest covered attorney fees. Results may vary. Prior outcomes do not guarantee a similar result.
How is a buyback different from cash and keep?
With a buyback, the manufacturer takes the vehicle back, pays off the loan or lease and refunds the owner, minus any use allowance the state allows. With cash and keep, the owner keeps the vehicle and gets a cash payment.
What does it cost to bring a BMW lemon law claim with Easy Lemon?
There is no upfront fee. Lemon law fee-shifting statutes generally make the manufacturer pay the attorney fees. In this case, part of the attorney fees came out of the settlement.
BMW Owner?

Driving a BMW With Repeat Repairs?

A BMW that needs the same repair again and again may qualify under your state's lemon law. The manufacturer pays our fees, not you, and we take on BMW cases like this one regularly.

See Our BMW Lemon Law Page →
Related Resources

Learn More

Related Case Results

Lemon Law Attorneys in New Jersey

Check If I Qualify → (855) 435-3666
INSTANT QUALIFICATION
100% Free & Confidential · Takes 30 Seconds
Vehicle Situation Contact

What's your vehicle? 🚗

Let's see if your car qualifies for a lemon law claim.

🔒 Lemon law claims have strict filing deadlines, don't wait.
$50M+**
Recovered
97%*
Resolution Rate
No Attorney’s Fees†
Unless We Recover
★★★★★§
Client Rating