Lemon Law Qualifications

What Qualifies for Lemon Law

Many drivers wonder what qualifies for Lemon Law, but automakers don’t make it easy to understand your rights. The short version: if the same defect keeps coming back despite multiple repair attempts, you could be eligible for a refund, a replacement, or a cash settlement.

Millions Recovered for Drivers 97%^* Resolution Rate 2022 or Newer Vehicles Fast and Simple Process

Call 855-435-3666

The 60-second answer

Your car likely qualifies under your state's lemon law if it has a substantial defect the dealer cannot fix after 3-4 repair attempts, OR has been out of service 30+ cumulative business days while under warranty. The federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act (15 U.S.C. §§2301–2312) provides a parallel route when state thresholds don't fit your case.

Under both statutes, the manufacturer pays the consumer's attorney fees when the consumer prevails, no attorney's fees unless we recover for you. Easy Lemon represents drivers nationwide. Check open recalls on your VIN at NHTSA Recall Lookup.

Watch our explainer on what makes a car qualify under lemon law. Watch the Videos →

$30M+^**

Recovered

97%^*

Resolution Rate

No Attorney’s Fees^†

Unless We Recover

★★★★★^§

Client Rating

YouTube · Easy Lemon

Does My Car Qualify for Lemon Law? Check Requirements & Get a Refund

How Lemon Law Determines If Your Car Qualifies

Your car qualifies when a substantial defect keeps coming back after a reasonable number of repair attempts, or keeps the car in the shop for weeks, while it is under warranty. Not every car issue qualifies. A dashboard rattle usually won't. A RAV4 Hybrid that went back to a New York dealer four times for one defect, and sat there more than 140 days, is the history the statute was written for.

Why Choose Easy Lemon for Your Lemon Law Case?

We check the repair orders against your state's Lemon Law criteria: the mileage at each visit, the complaint as the service writer wrote it, the days in the shop.

We pursue the remedy you choose: a refund, a replacement, or, where the law or the manufacturer allows it, a cash settlement that lets you keep the car.

Demand letters, manufacturer forms, filings and the back-and-forth over numbers are on us.

Pay nothing upfront—no attorney’s fees unless we recover for you; in qualifying claims the manufacturer pays attorney’s fees.

If a manufacturer stops answering, we follow up in writing, with dates.

Three or four visits for the same complaint is usually enough to have the file reviewed.

Defects That Qualify vs Issues That Don't

Not every mechanical problem is a lemon law case. The left column lists defects that can support a buyback, replacement, or cash settlement. The right column lists problems that usually fall outside the statute.

✓ Likely qualifies	✗ Likely does not qualify
Transmission slipping, shuddering, or refusing to engage	Routine maintenance items (oil, brake pads as wear items)
Engine stalling, no-start, or persistent rough running	Cosmetic damage caused by the owner
Electrical system failures (lighting, infotainment, sensors)	Wear-and-tear at high mileage outside warranty
Brake system defects covered by warranty	Aftermarket modifications causing the issue
Steering or suspension failures	Damage from a collision or accident
Open NHTSA recalls not fixed by the dealer	Issues from neglected maintenance
Defects affecting safety, value, or use of the vehicle	Issues that reasonable use can prevent

Get Paid for Your Defective Car

Getting paid for a defective car starts with a demand the manufacturer has to answer. A South Florida couple's new Kia Telluride went to the dealer four times for a rear noise nobody could trace, and was out of service 40+ days. After our demand under the Florida Motor Vehicle Warranty Enforcement Act, Kia agreed to a full buyback. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Here’s how we turn your defective car into a payout:

We start with the history: repair orders, warranty dates, recall work. That shows whether you qualify under the state Lemon Law, the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, or both.

Next come notice letters and the manufacturer's claim forms. A Florida dispute goes to the state-run New Motor Vehicle Arbitration Board; New Jersey has no arbitration requirement.

Then we negotiate toward the refund, replacement or settlement the statute allows, and you decide on each offer.

Your car doesn't have to be brand new to qualify. The 2022 Jeep Wrangler we handled in South Carolina had its first two repair visits inside the state's 12-month/12,000-mile window. By 28,280 miles the wobble hit at 70 mph, so the claim also relied on the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act.

What Defects Qualify for Lemon Law?

Defects that substantially impair the car's use, value, or safety qualify for Lemon Law; minor inconveniences don't. A loose trim piece is an annoyance. An airbag light that won't stay off is not. Here is how the qualifying problems usually group:

Major Mechanical Failures

Engine breakdowns, overheating, or power loss
Transmission failures, gear slipping, or stalling
Brake malfunctions or unsafe stopping distances
Power steering failures or sudden loss of control

Serious Safety Defects

Airbags failing to deploy or faulty safety sensors
Electrical failures causing power loss or light malfunctions
Unintended acceleration or cruise control issues
Doors, windows, or locks that fail unexpectedly

EV & Hybrid Defects

Battery failures that prevent normal operation
Software bugs that cause unpredictable performance
Charging malfunctions or extreme range loss

Reviewing warranty and policy documents to confirm lemon law qualification

Do You Qualify for Lemon Law? Here’s How to Tell

You may qualify if these points describe your car. Use the dates and mileage on your repair orders rather than memory; those are what the manufacturer checks. You could be eligible if:

The defect affects safety, drivability, or resale value

The manufacturer failed to fix the issue after multiple repair attempts

The vehicle has spent 30+ days in the shop for repairs

The problem started while the car was under warranty

A car that misses the state's standard Lemon Law criteria can still support a breach of warranty claim under the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act. Our 2025 Kia K5 GT claim in Wisconsin used both statutes; the transmission had been replaced twice.

Securing lemon law compensation from the vehicle manufacturer

How Much Can You Get From a Lemon Law Claim?

How much depends on the remedy and your state's formula. In many states a refund is the price paid minus a reasonable allowance for use. You could be owed:

A full refund – Including purchase price, taxes, and loan payments.

A replacement vehicle – Of equal value, free of defects.

A cash settlement – If you prefer to keep the car.

Reimbursement for repairs, rentals, and towing fees.

No attorney's fees unless we recover – in qualifying claims, the manufacturer pays your legal costs.

First offers can be very low. Toyota's first response to our demand on that New York RAV4 Hybrid was $1,000 toward attorney fees, with no repurchase. The case ended in a full buyback. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Our Services

Lemon Law Services by Type of Claim

Lemon Law claims don't all look like a new sedan with a bad transmission. Each type below turns on a different question.

Used Car Lemon Law Claims

A used car can still be a lemon. New York has a separate Used Car Lemon Law, §198-b, and New Jersey has one for used vehicles bought from dealers. Elsewhere the question is usually whether the manufacturer's warranty was still in force when the defect showed up. Certified pre-owned and dealer-warranty cars can fit, depending on the state.

Leased Vehicle Lemon Law Claims

Leased cars qualify for Lemon Law protection in most states. A client's leased Volkswagen ID. Buzz in New Jersey was towed in when the charging port would not open and the van would not start, and three repair visits added up to more than 111 days in the shop before we resolved the claim. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Luxury and High-End Vehicle Claims

Price does not change the statute: a luxury car qualifies on the same terms as any other. A Texas client's 2022 Porsche Cayenne first went back to the dealer at 868 miles. The same dealer saw it nine times over two-plus years and replaced the central computer and the assistance-systems control unit, and the park-assist fault kept coming back.

Defective Safety System Cases

Some statutes set a lower bar for safety defects. Texas and Connecticut require two repair attempts for a serious safety defect instead of four, and New Jersey requires one. A New York client's 2024 Tesla Cybertruck, delivered with 15 miles on it, lost brake pressure; Tesla service worked on the brakes four times without a permanent fix.

Electric and Hybrid Lemon Law Cases

EV and hybrid claims tend to involve batteries, charging and software. A Texas client's 2024 Audi Q8 e-tron Prestige leaked coolant into the rear motor housing in its first year, and the dealer replaced the motor. After that the electrical faults piled up: three visits, 166 days out of service. An EV or hybrid with a record like that can qualify.

Commercial Vehicle Lemon Law Claims

Whether a work truck or van is covered depends on your state's statute and how the vehicle was bought and used. Florida's and Texas's statutes, like many others, cover vehicles bought for personal, family, or household use, so that gets checked first.

RV and Motor Home Lemon Law Claims

Motorhome rules differ from car rules. Florida allows 60 days out of service for recreational vehicles instead of 30, and Texas covers towable RVs. Repeated drivetrain, electrical, or structural defects usually drive an RV or camper claim.

Fleet and Business Vehicle Claims

Company and fleet vehicles can qualify where the state statute reaches them, and we handle claims for businesses whose company vehicles keep failing under warranty.

Dealer Fraud & Misrepresentation Lemon Law Claims

Hidden damage, rolled-back mileage and false warranty claims are claims against the dealer, separate from a lemon claim against the manufacturer.

Why Most Drivers Don’t File a Claim (and Why You Should)

Usually because they assume they don't qualify, and a few myths do most of the damage:

“I have to keep repairing my car before I can file.” False. After a reasonable number of repair attempts you can stop going back. Some states, Florida and Michigan among them, do want written notice and one final repair attempt first.

“Lemon Laws only apply to new cars.” False. A used car still under warranty can qualify in many states, and New York wrote a separate statute just for used cars.

“Filing a claim will hurt my credit score.” False. Lemon Law claims have no impact on your credit.

“Legal fees are too expensive.” False. You pay nothing upfront, and in qualifying claims the manufacturer pays the attorney fees.

If you qualify, you may be entitled to a refund, a replacement, or a cash settlement.

Why Choose Easy Lemon?

We handle Lemon Law exclusively. Our attorneys have 25+ years of combined experience, we have offices in Manhasset, Newark, Miami and Dallas, and there are no attorney's fees unless we recover for you.

Focused Experience

Lemon Law is the only kind of case we take, so your file isn't waiting behind other practice areas.

You Decide on Offers

Every offer reaches you with our read on it under your state's law. Taking it or not is your call.

$0 Upfront Cost

You pay nothing upfront—no attorney’s fees unless we recover for you.

Lemon Law Only

Repair orders, buyback paperwork, and each state's notice and arbitration rules make up the daily work.

Don’t Let Automakers Get Away With It

You didn't build the defect, so you shouldn't be the one paying for it. Send Easy Lemon the repair orders and a free review will tell you where the claim stands.

Real Results. Real Stories.

What Our Clients Say

Common Questions About Lemon Law Qualifications

How Many Repairs Do I Need Before Filing? +

Most states require two to four failed repair attempts for a recurring defect, or 30+ days out of service due to repairs. New York sets it at four attempts or 30 cumulative calendar days. Pennsylvania uses three attempts. New Jersey uses 20 cumulative calendar days, and one failed attempt is enough there for a serious safety defect.

Does the Lemon Law Cover Used Cars? +

In many states, yes, if the car is still under the original manufacturer's warranty or was sold with a dealer-backed or extended warranty. New York has a separate Used Car Lemon Law, §198-b. Where no lemon statute applies, other consumer protection laws may.

What If My Car Has a Recall? +

A recall alone, or even several, doesn't make a car a lemon; what matters is whether the defect keeps coming back after repeated repair attempts. A New York client's 2023 Mercedes-Benz GLE Coupe got a recall update to the engine and fuel pump during a 74-day first visit, and the check engine light was back within weeks. If a defect survives the fix, or the manufacturer can't supply a timely fix or part, the car may still meet Lemon Law requirements.

What If I’m Offered Arbitration? +

Talk to us before you agree to it. Florida requires the state-run New Motor Vehicle Arbitration Board first. Texas complaints go to the TxDMV for a hearing. New Jersey has no arbitration requirement. Manufacturer-run programs can be slow or end in a low number.

How Long Does the Process Take? +

Timelines vary by manufacturer, by state, and by the facts of the claim. Manufacturers sometimes stall, and a complete file, sent early, gives them less room to do it. Filing deadlines are set by statute. In Texas the deadline is six months after the earliest of warranty expiration or 24 months/24,000 miles from delivery. In Florida, the request for state board arbitration is due within 60 days after the 24-month Lemon Law rights period ends.

Can I Qualify for Lemon Law If My Warranty Expired? +

Yes, if the defect started while the car was under warranty, you may still have a case even though the warranty has since expired. In New York the defect must be reported within 18,000 miles or 2 years, whichever comes first, and suit can be brought up to four years from delivery. The first repair order is usually the proof of when the defect was reported. Federal warranty law may add options.

What If the Dealership Refuses to Acknowledge the Problem? +

You can still prove the defect without the dealer's agreement. A Nevada client's 2024 Lincoln Navigator vibrated when braking; one visit found loose chassis bolts, and on another she was told the vibration was within specification. In negotiations Ford confirmed its engineers had measured it at 0.04g. A repair order that says “could not duplicate” still records the complaint, and in many states that visit can count as a repair attempt.

Does Lemon Law Cover Intermittent Issues? +

Yes, if an issue repeatedly occurs and impacts safety, drivability, or value, it may still qualify under Lemon Law. A new 2025 Audi Q5 in Connecticut first went back at 8,008 miles with a check engine light. Over four visits the light kept returning after being cleared, and the fuel cap popped off about three minutes after it was tightened, even after it was replaced. Neither problem showed every day. Both were on the repair orders.

Can I File a Claim If I Bought My Car From a Private Seller? +

Usually not under the Lemon Law itself, since most Lemon Laws only apply to dealership purchases. A private seller who misrepresented the car's condition, rolled back the mileage or concealed a defect may be liable under consumer protection or fraud law.

Can I File a Lemon Law Claim If I’m Still Financing My Car? +

Yes. You don't need to own the car outright, and many successful Lemon Law claims involve financed or leased vehicles. In a buyback the loan balance is typically paid off and your payments may be refunded. A leased 2025 Kia Sorento in Ohio needed a jump start the day it left the dealer; after four repair visits and 41 days out of service, Kia bought it back and the lease was unwound. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Still Have Questions?

Our team reviews every case individually. The fastest answer is a free consultation — no pressure, no commitment.

Offices & Mailing Address

Our Easy Lemon Locations

Easy Lemon, New York

1129 Northern Blvd., Suite 404
Manhasset, NY 11030

New York lemon law attorneys → View Profile →

Easy Lemon, Texas

1341 W. Mockingbird Lane, Suite 600W
Dallas, TX 75247

Dallas lemon law attorneys → View Profile →

Easy Lemon, New Jersey

972 Broad St, Suite 300
Newark, NJ 07102

New Jersey lemon law attorneys → View Profile →

Easy Lemon, Florida

333 SE 2nd Ave, Suite 2000
Miami, FL 33131

Miami lemon law attorneys → View Profile →

Mail & process service

California Mailing Address

10880 Wilshire Blvd Ste 1290
Los Angeles, CA 90024

Mail and service of process only.

View Profile →

Learn More

Resolving Your Lemon Law
Case Has Never Been Easier

Our experienced attorneys handle everything — from paperwork to manufacturer negotiations. You focus on your life, we'll get you results.

Call (855) 435-3666